Whit's Frozen Custard - Sunbury Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Whit's Frozen Custard
101 W Cherry St, Sunbury, OH 43074, USAOpens 12:00 PM
Order for later
Featured Items
💙🩵Cookie Monster Quart
$12.00
🥜🍫Buckeye Quart |🥇 best seller
$12.00
🍀🍫Mint Chocolate Chip Quart
$12.00
🍪Cookies & Creme Quart
$12.00
🍦Vanilla Quart | Most loved ❤️
$12.00
Custard Sandwich 6pk
$21.00
🌊🧂 Sea Salt Caramel Quart | owners pick!
$12.00
🍫Chocolate Quart | POPULAR ITEM
$12.00
🎂🎉Birthday Cake Whittie
$7.50
🥜🍦Fluffer Nutter Quart
$12.00
🩷🍫Black Raspberry Chip Quart
$12.00
🍓Strawberry Quart
$12.00
📆Flavor of the Week Quart
$12.00
🌰Butter Pecan Quart
$12.00
🌴🥥Almond Joy Quart
$12.00
Buckeye Whittie
$7.50
🟤🍫Double Dark Chocolate Whittie
$7.50
Chocolate Dipped Drumstick
$9.00
🪵🍫S’Mores Whittie
$7.50
🍦Vanilla - Pint
$9.00
❓🔎Surprise me with any Flavor Pint
$9.00
💟Sugar Sprinkle Whittie💟
$7.50
❓🔎Mystery Whittie
$7.50
🌟Chocolate Chip Vanilla Whittie | Most Popular
$7.50
Full Menu
12:00 pm - 8:40 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
💙🩵Cookie Monster Quart
Vanilla Custard with Cookies 'n' Cream, Cookie Dough, and Chocolate Syrup. Nom Nom!
$12.00
🥜🍫Buckeye Quart |🥇 best seller
Peanut Butter Custard with Chopped Reese's® and Peanut Butter Swirls. O-H!
$12.00
🩷🍫Black Raspberry Chip Quart
Black Raspberry Custard hand mixed with Dark Chocolate Flakes.
$12.00
🍪Cookies & Creme Quart
Whit’s creamy vanilla custard loaded with cookies ‘n crème pieces
$12.00
🌟Chocolate Chip Vanilla Whittie | Most Popular
Vanilla Custard Sandwiched in Between Two Chocolate Chip Cookies.
$7.50
🍓Strawberry Quart
Strawberry custard hand mixed with fresh strawberries
$12.00
🪵🍫S’Mores Whittie
It's our version of the campfire classic - 2 store baked s'mores cookies are filled with a generous scoop of whit's vanilla custard, topped with chocolate drizzle and frozen to perfection
$7.50
🟤🍫Double Dark Chocolate Whittie
$7.50
🎂🎉Birthday Cake Whittie
Chocolate custard sandwiched in between two peanut butter cookies.
$7.50
🥜🍦Fluffer Nutter Quart
Our vanilla custard hand mixed with peanut butter and marshmallow swirls
$12.00
🍦Frozen Custard Quarts🍦
🍦Vanilla Quart | Most loved ❤️
Our Original smooth and Creamy Vanilla Custard.
$12.00
🍫Chocolate Quart | POPULAR ITEM
Our classic rich chocolate custard, hand make in our store.
$12.00
📆Flavor of the Week Quart
$12.00
🌴🥥Almond Joy Quart
Toasted Coconut Custard hand mixed with Dark Chocolate Flakes, Almonds, and Toasted Coconut Flakes.
$12.00
🩷🍫Black Raspberry Chip Quart
Black Raspberry Custard hand mixed with Dark Chocolate Flakes.
$12.00
🥜🍫Buckeye Quart |🥇 best seller
Peanut Butter Custard with Chopped Reese's® and Peanut Butter Swirls. O-H!
$12.00
🌰Butter Pecan Quart
Butterscotch Custard hand mixed with Pecan Halves.
$12.00
💙🩵Cookie Monster Quart
Vanilla Custard with Cookies 'n' Cream, Cookie Dough, and Chocolate Syrup. Nom Nom!
$12.00
🍪Cookies & Creme Quart
Whit’s creamy vanilla custard loaded with cookies ‘n crème pieces
$12.00
🥜🍦Fluffer Nutter Quart
Our vanilla custard hand mixed with peanut butter and marshmallow swirls
$12.00
🍀🍫Mint Chocolate Chip Quart
Mint custard loaded with dark chocolate flakes.
$12.00
🌊🧂 Sea Salt Caramel Quart | owners pick!
Caramel custard with hand mixed with caramel swirls and a dash of sea salt.
$12.00
🍓Strawberry Quart
Strawberry custard hand mixed with fresh strawberries
$12.00
🍦🍪Whitties: frozen cookie sandwiches
Our store baked cookies are filled with a generous scoop of our delicious custard, then they are frozen to perfection.
🌟Chocolate Chip Vanilla Whittie | Most Popular
Vanilla Custard Sandwiched in Between Two Chocolate Chip Cookies.
$7.50
❓🔎Mystery Whittie
We will select any whittie in our case
$7.50
🎂🎉Birthday Cake Whittie
Chocolate custard sandwiched in between two peanut butter cookies.
$7.50
Buckeye Whittie
Our buckeye custard loaded between 2 store baked peanut butter cookies.
$7.50
🟤🍫Double Dark Chocolate Whittie
$7.50
💟Sugar Sprinkle Whittie💟
We take 2 store baked sugar cookies, fill with a generous scoop of whit's vanilla custard then we roll in rainbow or seasonal sprinkles. fun item alert
$7.50
🪵🍫S’Mores Whittie
It's our version of the campfire classic - 2 store baked s'mores cookies are filled with a generous scoop of whit's vanilla custard, topped with chocolate drizzle and frozen to perfection
$7.50
🔴🟡 🔵🟢 M&M Cookie Whittie
Our store baked m&m cookies are filled with a generous scoop of our delicious vanilla custard, then frozen to perfection.
$7.50
🌭🥤Food & Drinks🥤🌭
Whit's Old Fashioned Orange Soda
$5.00
Whit's Old Fashioned Root Beer
$5.00
Bottled Soda
$3.50
🍌🍫Chocolate Dipped Bananas
Chocolate Dipped Banana
A fresh banana frozen on a stick, dipped in chocolate
$4.50
Chocolate Dipped with Crunch Coat
A fresh banana frozen on a stick, dipped in chocolate and coated with peanut butter crunch coat
$4.75
Chocolate Dipped with Sprinkles
A fresh banana frozen on a stick, dipped in chocolate and coated with sprinkles
$4.75
Chocolate Dipped with Nuts
A fresh banana frozen on a stick, dipped in chocolate and coated with chopped nuts
$5.00
Dipped Drumsticks
We add frozen custard to a waffle cone, then dip in chocolate coating and add optional toppings like sprinkles or nuts
Chocolate Dipped Drumstick
$9.00
Custard Sandwich 6pk - great for groups
You'll get 6 of our signature custard sandwiches, chocolate wafers filled with custard.
Custard Sandwich 6pk
$21.00
🐾Pup Cups & More
🦴🐾Pup Cup / Dog Sundae
$3.50
🐧Little Whit Penguin Plush
$20.00
🍦Frozen Custard Pints🍦
🍦Vanilla - Pint
Our Original smooth and Creamy Vanilla Custard.
$9.00
🍫Chocolate - Pint
Our classic rich chocolate custard.
$9.00
📆Weekly Flavor - Pint
$9.00
❓🔎Surprise me with any Flavor Pint
We’ll pick any flavor we have in stock and send it your way. You may just discover your next favorite flavor! Note: your item will be labeled with all ingredients listed, may contain dairy, soy, nuts or other allergens.
$9.00
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash